24 November, 2019

The winners are here

The end-of-year gala of WA took place yesterday and the winners of the various categories were announced. I am very glad because the ones who were at the top of my list were the ones who won the title.



There was no doubt that D. Muhammad was going to prevail in the women's category. Two world records and a world title had put her above everyone else. And I must add that, while I do like a lot S. McLaughlin, when I see them running side by side I must admit that Muhammad has a far better technique. McLaughlin is stronger and as she is younger the future is hers, but for the time being Muhammad is the best female low-hurdler.


E. Kipchoge won the athlete of the year title for a second year in a row. His sub-2 marathon is such an iconic performance that he was the obvious choice for the title. And since there have been precedents of athletes winning back to back titles I was rather confident in my choice. (This year he did not attend the gala and he accepted his prize through videoconference). 



Y. Mahuchikh won the female rising star title as I predicted. And in fact, she had won also the european title a few weeks back. Her nomination was a rare occasion to see the WA vice-president in an official photo. Why do I have the impression that S. Bubka is not on excellent terms with sir Sebastian?


The men's rising star award went to S. Barega. As you may remember my preference went to N. Kaul who won the european rising star title. However the WA have different criteria and thus Kaul could not make the list. Once I saw the five finalists I expressed the hope that J. Ingebrigtsen could obtain the title as a consolation for an excellent year spoiled by a below-par championship. But this was a vain wish. And in fact it is funny to remark that the title went to Barega who won the silver medal and not to Girma who lost the gold medal on the finish line. (In the photo above Barega is receiving his prize by none other than H. El Guerrouj).



There was no surprise for the fair play award. B.S. Dabo, from Guinea-Bissau won the title for having helped his fellow runner J. Busby from Aruba to reach the finish line in the heats of the 5000 m. I stand by my (positive) comments in my championships report.



The photograph of the year went to a photo of S.A. Fraser-Pryce jubilant at the finish of her 100 m. It is definitely not my choice. I prefer and by far the photo of Patrick Smith which shows P. Frederick of Antigua competing in the high jump final at the Lima, 2019, Pan American Games.



And one last thing. You have to give it to Sir Sebastian, tradition is a very important thing and he is very careful about that. This year he organised a ceremony in honour of  the best milers, going back to R. Bannister (who passed away last year and was represented by his daughters). It was a great occasion to see again, side by side, F. Bayi and J. Walker. (If you haven't watched the 1974 Commonwealth Games 1500 final here is a link to youtube, but make sure you watch it with the sound off). Alas, Sir John is greatly diminished (he is suffering from Parkinson's disease) but Bayi is always in great shape. In fact it was the race of T. Cheruiyot in Doha which reminded me of the fabulous 1974 race. (Unfortunately there is no decent video of the 1500 m men's final in Doha, which is really a pity).


20 November, 2019

The finalists' list is out

The World Athletics (that's the new brand name of the IAAF, and a somewhat awkward one without a dangling "federation", "organisation" of whatnot) has published the list of the five finalists among which they will select the athlete of the year. 

The men finalists are

Joshua Cheptegei (UGA)
Sam Kendricks (USA)
Eliud Kipchoge (KEN)
Noah Lyles (USA)
Karsten Warholm (NOR)

I stand by my previous choice of Kipchoge and Warholm in that order. My choice for third goes to Cheptegei. I must confess that I had hesitated a lot before opting for Barshim for third place but Cheptegei was my very next choice so it is natural to give him the third place now. As to what the WA will finally decide, I cannot make any confident prediction. Kipchoge was nominated last year, so will he carry the trophy for a second year in a row? (But then there is the precedent of Bolt, so one never knows). Warholm obtained the european athlete of the year title, so this, somehow, diminishes his chances. Could it be Cheptegei? Well, I cross my fingers.

And the women

Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce (JAM)
Sifan Hassan (NED)
Brigid Kosgei (KEN)
Dalilah Muhammad (USA)
Yulimar Rojas (VEN)

Muhamamd, Hassan and Kosgei are my top three in that order. My favourite is clearly Muhammad. I don't believe that Fraser-Pryce is worth a nomination among the five finalists. To my eyes she is not even the best female sprinter of the year. Had I to decide who should have been among the top five I would have chosen Chepkoech instead of Fraser-Pryce. 

And one final remark. Perusing the WA finalists list one remarks that we have 80 % of runners, 20 % of jumpers and 0 % of throwers (to say nothing of the combined events). Does this really reflect today's situation in athletics? I am not quite convinced.

The rising stars list was also made public a few days ago.

Here is the men's list

Selemon Barega (ETH)
Alison dos Santos (BRA)
Lamecha Girma (ETH)
Jakob Ingebrigtsen (NOR)
Mykhaylo Kokhan (UKR)


And the women's list

Britany Anderson (JAM)
Lemlem Hailu (ETH)
Yaroslava Mahuchikh (UKR)
Glenda Morejon (ECU)
Sha’Carri Richardson (USA)



When it comes to the rising starts list mine diverges appreciably from the one of the IAAF. One reason for this is that the IAAF limits this list to athletes who are in the U20 category, while I don't. If an athlete is 21 or 22 and to my eyes she/he is a rising stard I do not hesitate to include her/him in my list. Curiously the European Athletics federation is more permissive about the rising star's age. So the european rising stars this years were Y. Mahuchikh (I just hope she obtains the world award as well) and N. Kaul. 

Of course, I must also be honest and admit that I do not follow the middle- and especially the long-distances with the same interest as the rest. Hence the absence of Barega, Girma and Hailu from my lists. The one I was aware of was Sha’Carri Richardson but, since her participation at the US trials was less than satisfactory, I opted not including her in the list. In the case of Alison (Piu) dos Santos, this is a real omission of mine. 



It is due to the fact that, after the accident he suffered when still a baby he has no hair on a large part of his head, giving the impression that he is older than his 19 years. I am happy to repair this faux pas of mine here.


And I must make a special mention of J. Ingebrigtsen. I keep my fingers crossed for the IAAF to nominate him rising star of the year. They should have done this last year and nominate him jointly with A. Duplantis. This is precisely what the European Federation did. I have a tendency to classify him along with "grown-ups" which is not quite fair. He had an excellent year but both his finals in the World's were not as good as expected due to the tactics he chose. Let's see how the IAAF deals with this.

12 November, 2019

World's 2019 report: field events

M. Barshim was, together with Samba, the great hope of Qatar for a gold medal. But as in the case of Samba an injury early in the season did not allow a great optimism, in particular since his comeback at the end of August was rather disappointing, with an unheard-of (for him) 2.20. Still he managed to be in top shape for the World's and rewarded us with a fantastic contest. Already at the qualifiers he passed 2.29 without missing a height, qualifiers which saw many well known jumpers eliminated (Bondarenko, Przybylko, Ghazal,...). 
Barshim victorious
In the final Barshim had to fight the two russians, Akimenko and Ivanyuk, who both registered PB with 2.35. Barshim was flawless till 2.33 where he scared us by missing twice before succeeding on the third try. Then, together with the two russians, he passed 2.35 on his first try, but this was just enough for silver. And then Barshim showed that he is really the best high-jumper today, passing over 2.37, which proved too high for the russians (and the byelorussian Nedasekau, who finished 4th). Barshim is my favourite for next year's Olympics, provided he is injury free. 

Mahuchikh who improved the WJR twice
M. Lasitskene was the uncontested favourite of the women's high jump and did win in the end. But it was not a trivial thing. The event started in a quite tame way (Lasitskene started at 1.84 like all the others). Demireva went out at 1.89, a rather disappointing height for a 2 m jumper. Five athletes were still present when the bar was raised to 2 m (in fact 6 since Demidik had reserved her last attempt for this height). Licwinko had to contend herself with 1.98 but Levchenko, Mahuchikh and Cunningham succeeded (and, of course, Lasitskene).  The next height proved fatal for Levchenko and Cunningham, the latter obtaining the bronze medal on countback. Mahuchikh went on to register a World Junior Record with 2.02. But the surprise came at the next height where after Lasitskene had succeeded on the first attempt, Mahuchikh succeeded on the third try improving her just established record. It took 8 jumps for Lasitskene to secure the gold medal, while Mahuchikh needed 14 for silver.

The photo below is obviously not the one from the World's but I chose it because one can see Lasitskene celebrating with the russian flag for the first time after four years. I have already stated my opinion on punishing the authorised neutral athletes by depriving them of their national flag (and anthem).

Lasitskene at the World Military Games, 
together with Herashchenko and Levchenko

Both pole vault events were exciting ones. This started already with men's qualifiers which saw the elimination of olympic champion and World Record holder R. Lavillenie, world champion P. Wojciechowski, world indoor champion K. Filippidis and the talented E. Karalis. In the final, the height of 5.80 was the decisive one. Only three athletes managed to jump over it: S. Kendricks, A. Duplantis and P. Lisek. B.K. Lita Baehre was finally 4th ahead of olympic champion T. Graz, 5th, while world champion R. Holzdeppe and V. Lavillenie (the younger brother) shared the 6th position, all of them with 5.70. At the next height, 5.87, Duplantis and Lisek passed at the 2nd try while Kendricks need a third one. He recovered passing 5.92 on his first attempt while Duplantis needed three. Lisek tried once and he left the remaining two for 5.97 where he failed. At 5.97 Duplantis passed on the third attempt and was for a brief moment first, till Kendricks managed also to pass on his third attempt. Both failed at 6.02 and thus Kendricks won on countback because Duplantis had one more failure (at 5.87 and 5.92) compared to those of Kendricks. What an event!
The three medalists of pole vault.
Their friendly attitude won them a place in the fair-play short-list
Women's pole vault was the only hope for a greek medal. And in fact K. Stefanidi delivered although it was not of the colour she is accustomed to. 
The award ceremony for women's pole vault
The organisers had put the qualifying height at 4.60. But this was without counting on the progress of the discipline: as it turned out, 17 athletes obtained their qualification to the final. The latter was a quite demanding one as the opening height was 4.50 (all but J. Suhr started at this height) going immediately after to 4.70. N. Kyriakopoulou was among the ones who did not make it to the latter height. The next height was 4.80 and it saw the elimination, among others of K. Nageotte, R. Peinado, olympic champion J. Suhr and world champion Y. Silva. A. Bengtsson, whom I am following for quite a few years, was attempting a third jump at 4.80 when her pole broke. 
A. Bengtsson broke her pole while attempting 4.80
According to the rules she could retry, but she did not have a pole adapted to this height. So N. Guillon-Romarin lent her her pole and Bengtsson passed, finishing 6th of the event! A. Newman and H. Bradshaw were 5th and 4th respectively, with the same height. After 4.85 there were only three jumpers (in fact four, since Bradshaw had reserved one last jump to the higher height, one she did not pass). Stefanidi was 3rd having passed 4.85 on her second try and failing at 4.90 once (and at 4.95 twice). Sidorova and Morris passed 4.90 at their first attempt and, while we thought that we were heading for a barrage, Sidorova managed to pass 4.95 on her third try. (Sidorova is a better technician while Morris is faster and stronger, but, when the bar is really high, the technique does count). Morris was encouraging Sidorova all along which resulted in her being proposed for the fair-play award.
Morris and Sidorova congratulating each other
The men's long jump was a most curious event. The big name, M. Echevarria needed just one jump at 8.40 in order to qualify for the final. J. Henderson, R. Samaal and M. Tentoglou (he was below par in the final) did qualify thanks to their last jump, while world champion L. Manyonga was far from convincing. At the last, 12th, qualifying position was a young jamaican, T. Gayle who managed to make the final thanks to a last leap of 7.89. Everybody was expecting an easy victory and a huge jump for Echevarria but things turned out quite differently. The  barely known jamaican shocked everybody with a jump at 8.46. Jefferson was unfazed and with a 8.39 at his third attempt obtained silver. Echevarria was destabilised, started with two so-so jumps, improving in the third to 8.34. And just when we were expecting him to rise to the challenge, Gayle killed the competition with an incredible 8.69. Of course, Gayle had won the Shanghai Diamond league in May with 8.20, and had jumped 8.32 in London in July but nobody, absolutely nobody, was counting him among the possible winners of the title. It will be interesting to keep an eye on him over the next years.
Gayle flying towards the gold medal
Women's long jump was the opposite of the men's one in the sense of the forecast: the big favourite did win. The great absent from this championship was I. Spanovic who had injured her Achilles tendon while competing in Berlin on September 1st. The qualifiers reserved a surprise: World and olympic champion B. Reese could not qualify for the final. (To be honest I will not be missing Reese, since I absolutely hate her total absence of style. She is jumping on pure speed and force, reminding me of M. Jones who was also jumping without an ounce of style). 
Mihambo exhuberant after her victory
In the final M. Mihambo started by jumping a good half meter back from the foul line, then fouling  and could not take the lead till the third attempt when she landed at 7.30! She backed that with two jumps over 7 m, something that nobody else could match. M. Bekh was second with 6.92 and E. Brume 3rd with 6.91. T. Bowie, the 2017 world champion over 100 m came back to her first specialty, but her 6.81 leap was only enough for 4th place.
Taylor and Zango, celebrating
In men's triple jump C. Taylor prevailed once more. The qualifiers saw the elimination of world and olympic champion N. Evora and of european indoor champion N. Babayev. Taylor scared everybody by fouling the first two attempts but then pulled himself together and managed a decent 17.42 allowing him to pursue the competition. In the end Taylor won with 17.92 and W. Clay was second (just as in 2017) with 17.74. The competition was for me an occasion to discover the burkinabé jumper (and african champion) H. Zango who, with his last, 17.66, effort, pushed P. Pichardo (17.62) out of the podium. J. Díaz, whom I consider the future of the discipline, was 8th with 17.06, not bad for a first major championship.
Rojas in Doha. (You'll need a video in order to judge her style)
Given that she came to Doha with a recent PB of 15.41, Y. Rojas was everybody's favourite. And she did not disappoint. The qualifiers saw the elimination of olympic champion O. Rypakova. I was personally glad to see that my preferred jumper, 2018 athlete of the year, C. IbargĂĽen, was competitive, despite her recent injuries. In the final Rojas, jumping always in her awful-to-look-at style landed a huge 15.37 at the second attempt and the strife for gold was over. The two jamaicans S. Ricketts and K. Williams were occupying the two remaining podium places with 14.92 and 14.64 till the 5th jump when IbargĂĽen managed a 14.73 for bronze. World champion O. Saladukha was 5th with 14.52, while european indoor champion A. Peleteiro was 6th with 14.47. It's a pity P. Papachristou injured herself in September and missed the World's. I believe that she could have made the final.
IbargĂĽen showed that she is always competitive
There has never been a shot put competition of such a high level. Things started already at the qualifiers where 12 athletes threw over the qualifying minimum of 20.90. As was natural, this made some victims among which one finds M. Haratyk, O'Dayne Richards and B. Bertemes. The final started with Grouser sending the shot at 22.36 and Walsh shocking everybody with a huge 22.90. The game looked as it was over at this stage. In fact Walsh, perhaps too confident, started taking risks, most probably going for a world record, and ended up fouling 3 of his next 4 throws. After the fifth throw Walsh was always first, D. Romani second with 22.53 and Crouser third with 22.36. And then on the last throw Kovacs, who was 4th up to that point, had a huge throw measured at 22.91, and taking the lead. Crouser came next and he also managed to surpass himself with 22.90 passing over Walsh in countback. Neither Romani nor Walsh could react and had to leave the first two medals to the two americans. 
The three winners of the men's shot put
The two young talents Bukowiecki and Gill were 6th and 7th separated by just one cm. And a technical remark: all 12 throwers of the final are spinners. I think that the transition is now over, and the answer to the question I asked in my post right after Rio is that the rotational style is indeed totally dominating the shot put.
Thomas-Dodd is the only spinner among the shot put medalists
Women are always more conservative than men and here the percentage of spinners is less than 50 %. But it is growing and so I expect, in some not too distant future, the rotational style to dominate the women's discipline as well. The title in Doha was won by L. Gong with 19.55, followed by D. Thomas-Dodd with 19.47 and C. Schwanitz 19.17. World indoor champion A. Marton, still recovering from her injury, was 5th with 18.86 while olympic champion M. Carter could only manage a 9th place. 
Dacres and Stahl (the typo is, obviously, not mine)
D. Stahl had lost the 2017 title for a meagre 2 cm but this time he took his revenge. He had announced his intentions already at the qualifiers with a throw at 67.88. The qualifiers saw the elimination of world champion P. Malachowski, world vice champion P. Milanov and olympic champion C. Harting. L. Weisshaidinger barely managed to qualify throwing 9 cm more than the 13th contestant, but in the final he had a great series obtaining the bronze medal with 66.82. F. Dacres took temporarily the lead at the second throw with 66.94 but Stahl responded at the third with 67.59, which was enough in order to guarantee him the victory. 
PĂ©rez celebrating after her victory
I have always had a preference for Y. PĂ©rez. I like her style and, although she has yet to throw beyond 70 m, I believe that she is the best discus thrower of the moment. In Doha she dominated the event taking an early lead with 68.10. When D. Caballero went beyond this with 68.44, PĂ©rez responded with 69.17 securing the gold. S. Perkovic added another medal, this time bronze, to her collection with a throw at 66.72. The domination of these three throwers is really total with more than 3 meters separating the 3rd from the 4th. 
Caballero, PĂ©rez and Perkovic with their medals
Olympic and world vice-champion M. Robert-Michon had a most disappointing championship: while she threw 64.02 in the qualifiers, she could only manage 59.99 in the final for a 10th place. 
A. Peters, the surprise javelin world champion
I have been keeping an eye on A. Peters, in particular after his win at the Pan American Games with 87.31. But even so I did not expect him to win in Doha. On the other hand, Walcott, when he won the olympic title in London, had shown us that everything is possible. The event started in a disastrous way for Germany, since olympic champion T. Röhler was eliminated with 79.23 and european vice-champion A. Hofmann fared not much better with 80.06. J. Weber did make it to the final (but he could not go beyond a 6th place there). So the main hope for the german fans was world champion J. Vetter who qualified with a huge 89.35 throw at his first attempt. M. Kirt was second in the qualifiers with 88.36 and Peters third with 85.34. That order was going to be reversed in the final. Peters started with 86.69, which somehow destabilised his opponents. Kirt reacted with 86.21 and Vetter with 85.37 but it turned out that they could not go beyond that. Peters had an even better throw, 86.89, in his 4th attempt and that clinched the gold medal. Olympic champion K. Walcott and world champion Y. Yego had a disappointing championship. After throwing 84.44 and 83.86 in the qualifiers, respectively, they botched the final with Walcott throwing 77.47 and Yego fouling thrice.
The women's javelin medalists.
Notice that LĂĽ, on the right, is quite unhappy
The big favourite for women's javelin was H. LĂĽ. She is an experienced thrower who holds the Asian record with 67.59. Moreover this year she was unbeaten since April and she started by dominating the qualifiers with 67.27. But, as always, the final is a different story. LĂĽ took an early lead with 65.06 but in the 5th throw her compatriot Liu went beyond this with 65.88. LĂĽ could only respond with 65.49 and while gold and silver seemed to be chinese K.L. Barber shocked everybody with a last throw at 66.56 winning gold for Australia. 
Barber on her road to glory
Multiple world and olympic champion B. Spotakova did make it to the final with a 62.15 throw but, once in there, she could only manage 59.87 for a 9th place. 
The three four men's hammer medalists
P. Fajdek won his fourth world title in a row. He took control of the event right from the qualifiers and in the final he was the only one to go beyond 80 meters. Q. Bigot was second (one of the rare french medals in this championship) with 78.19. The third place of B. Halasz created a controversy. Throwing 78.18 at his first attempt he obtained the third place in front of W. Nowicki who managed 77.69 in his last throw. And then the polish team filed a protest, supported by the video where one could see that Halasz had fouled his bronze-winning throw. However, since the judge had validated the attempt, there was no going back. A "Judgement of Solomon" solution was needed and the IAAF did not hesitate: a second bronze medal was awarded to Nowicki and everyone was happy. Eighteen year old M. Kokhan was 5th with 77.39, earning a position among my top list of young talents. 
The women's hammer medalists
Muliple olympic and world champion A. Wlodarczyk could not defend her title this time. Having undergone a left knee surgery in July she decided to end her season there and prepare herself for Tokyo. This opened the way for the american and the remaining polish throwers. But there some laughed while others weeped. B. Andersen was eliminated in the qualifiers but the greatest shock was the elimination of world bronze medalist M. Kopron , who was viewed by many as the successor of Wlodarczyk. Then in the final G. Berry fouled thrice and was not even classified. It would have been interesting to see what would have happened had Berry won a medal. 
Berry in Lima (reminiscing Mexico)
(When she won gold in the Lima, 2019, Pan American Games this year she raised her hand during the national anthem protesting against injustice in America "and a president who's making it worse"). In the end Poland's honour was saved By J. Fiodorow who was second with 76.35, behind D. Price, 77.54, and in front of Z. Wang, 74.76. 
Klymets, a most graceful hammer thrower
I. Klymets improved twice her personal best with 72.93 in the qualifiers and 73.56 in the final. 

05 November, 2019

My choice of the year's best athletes

Usually this list is published earlier. However this year, since the season was quite long, with the World's taking place at the beginning of October, everything has been delayed. In fact I had to interrupt the publication of my report on the World's in order to publish the top list before the IAAF nominated their best athletes. (But don't worry, the report on field events will appear soon). 

So here is my list of the year's best men.

E. Kipchoge 

is again number one for me. What he did in Vienna with the first below 2 hours Marathon was almost superhuman. Of course, he has already been number one in the IAAF's list , as well as in mine, last year but I do not care. To my eyes he is the best.

K. Warholm 

has dominated the 400 m hurdles and has come within a breath of the world record. I am convinced that thanks to his efforts (and the competition from the remaining musketeers) the world record is in life support.

M. Barshim 

completes my podium. I spent quite some time choosing the third of the list and finally I decided that Barshim was worth it, be it only because he managed to rise to the occasion and win the title as he did.

And now without any specific order.

J. Cheptegei, who won both the world cross-country and the 10000 m in the championships.

T. Cheruyiot, who won the World's 1500 m as if there were no other competitors.

S. Kendricks, for his 6.06 m but also his incredible self-control during the World's competition.

C. Kipruto, who managed to come back from injury and win the 3000 m steeple in a"heroic" sprint.

P. Fajdek, for his fourth consecutive world title.

S. Gardiner, the absolute master of the 400 m in 2019.

N. Lyles, the best sprinter of the year.

D. Stahl, for winning the world title and making us hope for a new world record in a near future.

A. Peters, who shocked the athletics community by repeating Walcott's feat.

And a special mention for the three shot-putters, Kovacs, Crouser and Walsh who gave us the most thrilling shot put competition ever. 

And now, the list of best women.

D. Muhammad 

is my number one. There is no doubt whatsoever that she is the best ,despite the fact that S. McLaughlin manages to beat her from time to time. Two world records and a world title are more than enough to justify her position a the top of the list.

S. Hassan 

was the only athlete to win two individual gold medals in Doha. She dominated completely her events, registering a great European Record over 1500m with 3:51.95. And as if that was not enough, she broke also the mile world record with 4:12.33.

B. Kosgei

erased the old record of mixed-race Marathon of P. Radcliffe, with 2:14.04. She also ran faster than the official half-marathon world record but, unfortunately, on the slightly downhill course of the Great North Run.

And now without any specific order.

B. Chepkoech, who dominated the discipline of 3000 m steeple and won the world title.

M. Lasitskene, who won the world title with 2.04 and is our main hope for a new world record.

M. Mihambo, unbeaten in long jump, she registered a great 7.30 in Doha.

S. McLaughlin, even though she is number two in the 400 m hurdles she is perfectly worth her place in the top list.

S. Naser, for her superb (and a tad unexpected) victory and performance over the 400 m.

Y. Rojas, who is now at a few centimetres from the world record. (Ah, if only she improved her style).

Y. PĂ©rez, the best discus thrower today. Next stop, over 70 m.

There are two athletes who are not part of the IAAF list for reasons I have trouble understanding.

S. Miller-Uibo, who was unbeaten over 200 m with a world leading 21.74, and lost only one race over 400 m (admittedly the one that counted) but with a great performance.

D. Asher-Smith, who won the world title in the 200 m and was second in the 100 m with two great performances.

For reference, the IAAF list is 
MEN

Donavan Brazier (USA)
Christian Coleman (USA)
Joshua Cheptegei (UGA)
Timothy Cheruyiot (KEN)
Steven Gardiner (BAH)
Sam Kendricks (USA)
Eliud Kipchoge (KEN)
Noah Lyles (USA)
Daniel Stahl (SWE)
Christian Taylor (USA)
Karsten Warholm (NOR)

WOMEN

Beatrice Chepkoech (KEN)
Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce (JAM)
Katarina Johnson-Thompson (GBR)
Sifan Hassan (NED)
Brigid Kosgei (KEN)
Mariya Lasitskene (ANA)
Malaika Mihambo (GER)
Dalilah Muhammad (USA)
Salwa Eid Naser (BRN)
Hellen Obiri (KEN)
Yulimar Rojas (VEN)


The top list is usually complemented by that of the young talents. It is clear that both Naser and McLaughlin would qualify for the list (in fact McLaughlin won last year) but now they figure in the main list. A. Duplantis and J. Ingebrigtsen  do not appear in the main list but by now their reputation is so well established that I am reluctant to consider them as young talents (although they are young and immensely talented). 

So, here is my list of young talents. For men

N. Kaul

the decathlon World Champion is the indisputable number one. (He may still have been number one even if we had considered Duplantis and Ingebrigtsen). 

The next positions are occupied by 
J. Diaz, who jumped 17.49 at the triple jump this year and was 8th at the World's.
M. Kokhan, who threw 77.39 at the hammer throw and was 5th at the World's.
B.K. Lita Baehre, who was 4th in the pole vault at the World's with 5.70.

For women
Y. Mahuchikh

who broke twice the World Junior Record and was second at the World with 2.04 is young talent number one.

The two next positions are occupied by 
W. Yavi, who was 4th in the World's 3000 m steeple and won the Asian championships.
E. Oosterwegel, who was 7th in the World's heptathlon and is an excellent javelin thrower.

01 November, 2019

World's 2019 report: track events

The official IAAF position concerning the 2019, Doha, World Championships is that it has been successful. In the words of the IAAF vice-president X. Restrepo (1992 olympic bronze medalist) "the event was a complete success; the facilities for the athletes have been amazing and I think this championship was a big, big success". If we concentrate on the results that was definitely the case. And the facilities were OK. But the rest was really below par. The famous innovations announced with great pomp by the IAAF were limited to the ridiculous "crotch" camera. There was a real-time system giving the length of horizontal jumps: it functioned just two (or was it three) times. As soon as an athlete fouled (and the length of his jump was shown) it was decided to decommission the system. There were several mistakes in the announcement of results, too many for a world championship. But the worst of all was the empty stadium.
The half-empty Khalifa stadium 

Only 50000 tickets were sold (half a million were sold for the 2017, London, World's). As a result the capacity of the stadium was reduced to 21000 and the rest was covered with banners. In the end the organisers decided to make the entry free for the last three days. This resulted into an overcrowded stadium to the point that some ticket holders could not obtain their seat. At least the stadium was full when it was time to celebrate Barshim's victory in high jump.

I am ill at ease having to start with the men's 100 m.
Coleman winning the men's 100 m final
Coleman had been charged with three failures to properly file whereabouts information in a 12-month period, a potential anti-doping violation. But then, thanks to some legalese hocus-pocus, he was cleared and could participate in the World's winning the 100 m with 9.76 totally dominating a race which included the best sprinters in the world. We haven't seen such a domination since the Seoul, 1988, Olympics or the 2009 World's, where U. Bolt won with the current WR of 9.58.
The Seoul, 1988, 100 m final
Double doping offender J. Gatlin was second with 9.89, followed by A. De Grasse with 9.90. F. Tortu could participate in the first big final of his career, having one of the two best times for 4th place (just like Gatlin).

The same domination was exhibited by S-A. Fraser-Price in the women's event. She won with 10.71, with D. Asher-Smith second in 10.83 and M-J. TaLou third in 10.90. Olympic champion E. Thompson was 4th in 10.93. World indoor champion M. Ahouré was 5th with 11.02, while D. Schippers (double 200 m world champion) injured her adductor and had to withdraw from the final.
The women's 100 m final
In the women's 200 m everything conspired for D. Asher-Smith to win the race.  S. Miller-Uibo, the world leader this year with 21.74, opted for the 400 m. The 2017 world champion, D. Schippers withdrew due to injury. M-J. TaLou decided not to run feeling pain in her right knee. S-A. Fraser-Price scratched from the opening heats with soreness while E. Thompson withdrew after the heats due to an Achilles tendon problem. All these incidents opened the road for Asher-Smith who dominated the event with an excellent 21.88. B. Brown was second with 22.22 and M. Kambundji (who missed the 100 m final for those pesky thousands of second the IAAF persists in using even for athletes running in different series) obtained bronze with 22.51. I was very glad to see I. Lalova-Collio participate, at 35, in one more major final.

N. Lyles was the favourite of the 200 m and he did deliver. However his supremacy was far from absolute. Indeed at the 100 m mark he was in 4th position and it was thanks to a great finish that he managed to grab gold, with 19.83. To tell the truth I did appreciate him much more in the 4x100 m where it was only thanks to him that the US managed to finish first. DeGrasse was second with 19.95. Since the latter is an athlete that I appreciate enormously, I was very glad for his success in the championship. Coming back from a major injury that kept him far from the stadia for two years he managed to be in top shape for the competition that counted. Ecuadorian A. Quiñonez grabbed bronze with 19.98 thanks to a great finish, while A. Gemili, who was leading at the 100 m mark, was finally 4th. A minor disappointment was the elimination in the semis of trinidadian J. Richards who was bronze medalist two years ago (where he lost silver to W. VanNiekerk for one thousandth of a second).
Gardiner en route for the 400 m victory
The pre-race favourite for the 400 m was M. Norman but he went out in the semis, most probably victim of a bad season planning. (One cannot be in top shape in April, win the Diamond League, qualify in the US trials for the World's and still excel in the latter). In fact I have the impression that, had Norman been in top shape, he would have had a great difficulty to beat S. Gardiner, who dominated the race with an excellent 43.48. Colombian A. Zambrano grabbed the silver medal, with 44.15, thanks to a devastating finish. I was happy to witness the come-back of olympic and world champion K. James. Fighting his thyroid problems he managed to be in good shape just in time, but unfortunately the repeated races took their toll on his stamina and he could only finish 5th in the final.
The arrival of the fabulous women's 400 m race
Everybody was expecting a duel in the women's 400 m but what happened surpassed every expectation. Usually S. Miller-Uibo starts very fast while S. Eid Naser is more prudent relying on her powerful finish. In Doha the situation was reversed. Naser started very, very fast and managed to repeal the attack of Miller over the last stretch going on to win 48.14 to 48.37, two incredible times. S. Jackson was a distant third with 49.47 while the 2017 champion, P. Francis, had to contend herself with a 5th place. Given the outcome of the race one can wonder whether the choice of Miller-Uibo was the right one. I am convinced that she could have won the 200 m but then we wouldn't have had the chance to witness one of the best 400 m races ever. At this point one can deplore the structure of the program which does not allow the athletes to compete over both 200 and 400 m. However I recall that at one time the program was adapted so as to make it possible for A. Felix to compete in, and possibly win, both distances in the Rio Olympics, equaling the feats of Brisco-Hooks and Perec. (But Felix failed to make the US team in the 200 m and then she lost the 400 m title to Miller). There were two americans, two poles and two jamaicans in the final. It is thus not astonishing that these three nations shared the medals of the 4x400 m relay.

The men's 800 m crowned the pre-race favourite, D. Brazier, who won with 1:42.34. The race was given a very fast pace by puerto-rican W. Vázquez who had previously won his semi leading from gun to tape. He tried to use the same tactic in the final only to run out of steam in the final stretch and fade to 5th position. Good finishers Tuka and Rotich were 2nd and 3rd, with 1:43.47 and 1:43.82 respectively. P-A. Bosse, the 2017 champion was never in contention, and went out in the semis. 
Nanyondo and Nakaayi celebrating
The women's 800 m was a most interesting race. Already in the semi-final one could not help but remark two practically unknown runners from Uganda: H. Nakaayi and W. Nanyondo, excellent finishers and, for the former, a touch of aggressiveness. It was clear that they were going to play a role in the final. Thus the pre-race favourite, A. Wilson, decided to impose a very fast pace hoping to blunt the ugandans's sprint. All she managed to do was to burn herself out. On the final stretch there was nothing stopping Nakaayi, who won with 1:58.04. Wilson even lost the silver medal to R. Rogers 1:58.84 to 1:58.18. Nanyondo was 4th with 1:59.18 but she celebrated together with Nakaayi full of joy as if she had won herself. It is really refreshing to see at last a 800 m devoid of the masculine looks of the DSD trio.
Hassan after her 1500 m victory
S. Hassan was the only athlete to win two individual gold medals. The one of the 1500 m was in fact her second. Leading before the first lap was over she imposed her rhythm winning in a new european record of 3:51.95. Behind her the first 8 finalists registered personal or season bests. She could not run the 5000 m since it was taking place the same day as the 1500 m. (This is another absurd decision and I may come back to this point in a future past of mine). So H. Obiri got to keep the title she had won in 2017, although, even in the absence of Hassan, the competition was fierce. Obiri won with a championships record of 14:26.72, in front of M. Kipkemboi 14:27.49 and K. Klosterhalfen 14:28.43. Of the 15 athletes of the final 11 registered a personal best in this race. Hassan kicked off the championship with a victory over 10000 m in 30:17.62 leaving the ethiopians and kenyans behind her. All 8 first registered personal records. To my eyes, it is a question of time before Hassan runs a below 30 min 10000 m (erasing thus the 17-year old record of Radcliffe).
Cheruiyot's victory lokked even easier that that of Bayi
T. Cheruiyot won the 1500 m in an unorthodox way. Usually championship races are slow ones where everything is decided at the sprint. Cheruiyot decide to do things differently. He led practically from the outset never bothering for the competition. (In some way he reminded me of the fabulous 1974 Commonwealth race of F. Bayi, where he established a new world record with 3:32.2. You can find the photo of the finish in my article on Bob Hayes). Cheruiyot's tactic paid off and he went on to win in 3:29.26. Behind him two fast finishers, 2012 olympic champion T. Makhloufi and european indoor champion M. Lewandowski were 2nd and 3rd with 3:31.38 and 3:31.46 respectively. A disappointed J. Ingebrigtsen was out-sprinted and finished 4th in 3:31.70. M. Centrowitz, the 2016 olympic champion could do no better than 8th despite a season's best. The men's 5000 m was dominated by the ethiopians who arrived 1st, 2nd and 4th. M. Edris was the winner in 12:58.85, in front of Barega, 12:59.70 and Ahmed of Canada 13:01.11. There were three Ingebrigtsen's in the race Jakob (initially disqualified but reinstated on appeal, quite justifiably), Filip and Henrik. Jakob tried to take the lead at 300 m from the tape but was out-sprinted by the two ethiopians and finally finished 5th. It was definitely not the best championship for this brilliant young runner.

DabĂł helping Busby finish the race
There was an interesting incident during the heats of the 5000 m, which caused reactions (not all of them positive). J. Busby almost collapsed during the race and B. DabĂł who did not have any hope of qualifying sustained him and helped him reach the finish line. Busby was, of course, later disqualified, but DabĂł is candidate for the fair play award. I am convinced that DabĂł acted without any ulterior motive when he offered his help to Busby, and I would be happy if he obtained the fair play award. Now, concerning criticisms that athletes who cannot complete a 5000 m should not compete in a World Championship my answer is simple: it's the rules, man. Every country can enter one athlete in order to be represented in the championships. When the athlete in question participates in the 100 m, nobody is shocked. The same attitude should be prevail for the remaining events as well.
Cheptegei victorious over men's 10000 m
Two years ago I wrote that I was going to keep an eye on the young ugandan J. Cheptegei  who had finished 2nd in the 10000 m (and I did). Cheptegei matured as expected, went on to win the Commonwealth title over 5000 and 10000 m, then the world cross country title this year and crowned everything by a gold medal in the 10000 m of the world championship in 26:46.36 (a mere 0.5 second off the championship record). When Cheptegei launched his attack in the last lap there was nothing stopping him. Kejelcha and Kipruto could only follow securing the remaining medals in 26:49.34 and 26:50.32.

L. Desisa won the men's marathon in 2:10:40 where roughly 25 % of participants did not complete the race. R. Chepngetich won the women's race with 2:32.43 but here 40 % of the participants did not finish. Moreover the victor's time in the women's race is some 11 % over the WR, while in the men's race the difference is close to 7 %. The explanation is simple. Women competed with a temperature of 32 °C and a relative humidity of 74 %. For the men's race the conditions were much more comfortable with a temperature of 29 °C and humidity of just 51 %. If people were worrying about the Marathon race in Doha they should start doing so for Tokyo. In August the conditions in Tokyo are much worse with higher temperatures and higher humidity. (In fact the IAAF shows signs of realising this and there is talk of moving these long events to Sapporo in the north of Japan, which would be a great idea).

The men's 110 m hurdles was an eventful race. 
One can see clearly that McLeod is obstructing Ortega
McLeod had one of his technically bad races (he does this from time to time) and tried to catch Holloway who was slightly ahead of him using his main asset, his speed. He hit the 9th hurdle and fell on the 10th. Doing so he jostled Ortega who was on his right and was 3rd up to that point. The spaniards filed a protest and the final classification was: 1st Holloway 13.10, 2nd Shubenkov 13.15, 3rd P. Martinot-Lagarde 18 and O. Ortega 13.30. So Ortega finally got his bronze medal and Martinot-Lagarde go to keep his. I am sad for european indoor champion, M. Traikovic, who was one of the contenders for a medal up to the 5th hurdle. Unfortunately he hit the 6th one and the race was over for him.
The podium with the four medalists
There were four candidates for three medals in the women's 100 m hurdles race. And they would have been five if B. McNeal-Rollins had not been eliminated for a false start in the heats. In the end, it was world indoor champion N. Ali who prevailed, in 12.34, followed by world recordwoman K. Harrison, who won her first major medal in 12.46, and the 2015 champion D. Williams in 12.47. Commonwealth and African champion T. Amusan was 4th with 12.49. The only european present in the final was N. Visser, confirming thus her success at the Indoor Europeans this winter. Costa Rican A. Vargas, 5th in 12.64, is also a name to watch in the future.
The arrival of the unforgetable women's 400 m hurdles race
Just as in the 400 m the women's 400 m hurdles was a duel between the two best hurdlers of all time: D. Muhammad and S. McLaughlin. And this resulted into a breathtaking race.  Both started very fast, Muhammad got a small lead, and while McLaughlin covered part of it, it was Muhammad who crossed the line first, in a new world record of 52.16 with McLaughlin becoming the second performer of all time with 52.23. R. Clayton was 3rdÎĽ way, way back in 53.74 (a PB for her). 

The men's 400 m hurdles was a unique occasion to see all four musketeers competing in the same race. (The "musketeers" refers to my article of last year where I was talking about the new blood in the 400 m hurdles). As in Dumas' "The Three Musketeers" the low-hurdles musketeers are in fact four: K. Warholm, R. Benjamin, A. Samba and K. McMaster. and the 2019 World's were the first occasion for all of them to run together. It turned out that it almost didn't happen when McMaster hit the first(!) hurdle and was initially disqualified. Fortunately he was reinstated on appeal. The final was thrilling. Warholm and Benjamin started very fast followed by McMaster. At the 8th hurdle Samba was 6th or 7th. 
Men's 400 m hurdles: at the 8th hurdle
However he has a great finish and while he did not manage to catch the first two he passed McMaster obtaining the bronze medal for Qatar. 
Men's 400 m hurdles: arrival
Hadn't he been injured earlier in the season the race would have been even more exciting. The final classification: Warholm 47.42, Benjamin (who runs now for the US) 47.66, Samba 48.03 and McMaster 48.10.
Chepkoech celebrating her victory
The two steeple races were totally different. While in the women's race Chepkoech took the control from the beginning, running ahead of the pack and was never threatened, in the men's race we had to wait for the photo-finish in order to know the winner. Chepkoech won with a championship record of 8:57.84, while E. Coburn, the 2017 champion, was this time second with 9:02.35 and Krause 3rd with a national record of 9:03.30. (The european record of Galkina is under direct threat here). I will keep an eye on the 20 year old W. Yavi who finished 4th with 9:05.68. C. Kipruto was far from being the favourite for the men's race, having been injured earlier this year. In the final stretch El Bakkali was out of the gold medal race (he finished 3rd with 8:03.76) but Girma had a comfortable lead on Kipruto. However the sprint of the latter allowed him to retain the title he had won in 2017. The verdict: Kipruto 8:01.35, Girma 8:01.36.
The photo-finish for the men's 3000 m steeple
The US won the men's 4x100 m amid a scandal. During the semi-final they botched an exchange and should have been disqualified. Despite two protests by the Canadian and the Italian teams the americans were not disqualified and went on to win the final in a NR of 37.10. Great Britain was second in a european record of 37.36 (and so A. Gemili did go home with a medal in his pocket). An impressive japanese team with flawless exchanges was 3rd with an asian record of 37.43. What was amazing was Jamaica going out in the semis. Sic transit gloria mundi.
The jamaican women's 4x100 m team
The jamaican women took revenge for the defeat of the men winning with 41.85 in front of Great Britain, 41.85, and the US, 42.10.

Both 4x400 m relays were won by the US team. The men won with 2:56.69 ahead of Jamaica 2:57.90. The bronze medal went to Belgium 2:58.78 (thanks also to a fantastic anchor by Kevin BorlĂ©e), while the 2017 champions, Trinidad and Tobago, were 5th. The women's classification was: US first (with the two hurdlers Muhammad and McLaughlin in the team) 3:18.92, Poland second 3:21.89 and Jamaica third 3:22.37. 

The mixed relay was held for the first time in a World Championship. The US team won and established a new World record with 3:09.34. What was really interesting is that the US used two completely different teams in the semis and in the final. Jamaica was 2nd with 3:11.78 and Bahrain 3rd with 3:11.82. (And a little bit of gossip: all the bahraini athletes are in fact of nigerian origin. So, Nigeria should be proud for this medal). Most teams apply now what is the most sensible tactic, namely having a man at first and last relay with the two women in-between.  In the final only Poland used a different arrangement with the two men first and second but I do not think that it was a good choice. (In the heats the japanese team used a configuration WMMW but I fail to see the interest of this).
The US team winning the 4x400 m mixed relay
With the 4x400 women and the mixed relay gold A. Felix added two more medals in her collection.  

Don't wait for a report on race-walking. It is as if, for me, this discipline did not exist.